News & Insights

Letter from 106 Strong to House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries

Americans Can’t Afford for Congress to Get Permitting Reform Wrong. It’s About To.

Ten Terrible Consequences of the Senate Bill for Communities, Jobs, Public Lands, and Historic Places

November 13, 2026

The Honorable Hakeem Jeffries
House Democratic Leader
United States House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515

Dear Leader Jeffries:

Sir, we are 1,200 Tribal Nations, historic and environmental preservation organizations, community and civil rights organizations: the largest coalition ever formed to assert the essential civic and economic value of ensuring the public’s voice in historic preservation.

Please forgive us for being direct: why on God’s green earth is Congress preparing to eviscerate key elements of America’s environmental and historic preservation laws in a lame-duck session, just days after a watershed election, and before the newly elected House can examine the terrible consequences of a bill that members will have to defend for the next two years?

America urgently needs clean energy, reliable infrastructure, affordable housing, and lower electricity bills. But BAAJA’s nearly 500 pages have not been shown to deliver those outcomes. Instead, the bill would gut longstanding public safeguards, maximize federal agency discretion under an administration thoroughly rejected at the polls, restrict legal remedies even for clear violations of law, supercharge the expansion of data centers and fossil fuel exploitation, including on public lands, and cost hundreds of thousands of jobs tied to heritage protection and tourism, a proven economic driver for localities nationwide.

Nationwide exit polling reported widespread concern about data centers and substantial opposition to new facilities in voters’ own communities across party lines. Americans are worried about electricity bills, water, noise, and the industrial infrastructure arriving at their doorsteps. Those projects may not be stoppable, but BAAJA will eviscerate the federal rules governing public participation and review of such projects, to say nothing of mining, pipelines, and other fossil fuel projects. That is anti-democratic and the very strong-arm tactics that Americans just booted at the polls. A country desperate for more accountability is being offered a bill that eliminates it.

You have reportedly objected to the Senate’s process, which excluded the House, the American public, and Tribal Nations from consultation. Representative Jared Huffman, the next chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, has warned in no uncertain terms that the legislation will devastate environmental protections, undermine Tribal sovereignty, restrict judicial review, and pave the way for controversial projects. The House has not been given a sufficient public record to evaluate the bill’s far-reaching consequences. We ask you to insist that the House not vote on the bill until that record exists, and that record cannot be created in a heated rush in a lame duck session.

Ten Consequences We Ask You to Examine

 1. Communities will be silenced before decisions are made.

For sixty years, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act has given neighbors a way to identify historic places and explain their significance before federal decisions become irreversible. BAAJA would eliminate essential opportunities for public participation. The people who know where ancestors are buried or why a landscape matters will be excluded from decisions that permanently alter those places. See the short film here.

 2. Data centers will gain approvals in the dark.

Voters across party lines have expressed concern about data centers’ demands on electricity and water, noise, and industrial impacts. BAAJA’s infrastructure and permitting provisions will facilitate immediate approvals for data centers without public review. See how the bill is a massive giveaway to the datacenter industry here. The Department of Interior is excited about this possibility, including data center development on public lands. See here (page 10, 13).

 3. Tribal sovereignty and sacred places will be unprotected.

Tribal Nations are sovereign governments, not merely interested members of the public. Tribal organizations object that the legislation was developed without adequate government-to-government consultation and leaves federal agencies unilateral authority over places of religious and cultural importance. No amendments to the bill have resolved the primary objections identified by Tribal advocates. As Senator Armstrong has just admitted: “We didn’t bring the Tribes along on this and that’s really where we could have done better on it, in retrospect.” See a massive list of letters from Tribal Nations expressing their fundamental opposition to the bill: here.

 4. Entire categories of projects and harm will escape review.

What good does consultation do if 2/3rds of the projects that used to get reviewed for impacts to historic properties no longer qualify? BAAJA drastically narrows which federally connected projects count as undertakings and which harms agencies must consider. Visual, auditory, and setting-related impacts matter to sacred landscapes and historic neighborhoods even when no structure is physically demolished, and agencies will no longer have to consider those harms. Don’t like the visual impacts of President Trump’s arch? This move paves the way for an arch anywhere. See here.

 5. Agencies will set historic preservation aside completely on their own authority.

BAAJA gives a federal agency “sole discretion” to invoke undefined “other considerations” in determining that the public and Tribal Nations are not entitled to receive notice of or weigh in on historic preservation’s concerns. This discretion makes a farce out of the whole idea of consultation.

 6. Agencies could identify harm without meaningfully resolving it.

Section 106 has helped projects proceed with less damage by encouraging changes in routes, designs, construction methods, and mitigation measures. Under BAAJA, an agency can acknowledge imminent destruction of a burial ground, battlefield, historic neighborhood, or sacred landscape and nevertheless end any process without even trying to reach agreement on avoiding or mitigating that damage.

7. Courts will be stripped of basic tools to stop unlawful and irreversible harm.

A court cannot restore a demolished landmark or return an excavated burial ground to its original condition. BAAJA would restrict judicial remedies in permitting disputes, allowing unlawful projects proceed before a court can prevent permanent damage. Rep. Huffman has warned that the provisions could shield large ICE detention facilities from effective judicial review. The same applies to the President’s pet projects, like the Arch. That’s just one of the reasons 17 state attorneys general call for BAAJA to be dropped. See here.

8. The bill will eliminate full-time well-paid job in cultural and preservation industries, archaeology, architecture, landscape design, heritage tourism, and more.

Archaeologists, historians, architects, cultural resource management firms, and preservation specialists do essential work identifying threatened resources and finding solutions compatible with development. Removing projects from review or reducing required analysis will kill many jobs in these fields. Historic preservation also supports construction, museums, and heritage tourism, which also stand to lose business if the bill passes. See why the associations representing hundreds of thousands of architects are opposed here.

 9. The changes will smooth the way for controversial federal construction projects.

The proposed memorial arch near Arlington National Cemetery, the painting of the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, the threatened demolition of the Kennedy Center, and similar projects show why federal preservation safeguards matter. Rep. Huffman warns accurately that the administration will invoke the new law in pending litigation to thwart challenges to such projects. This isn’t only about President Trump; every future administration will hold the same expanded powers.

10. Public lands, climate, water, and public health will bear lasting costs.

Environmental groups warn that BAAJA will facilitate fossil fuel development and weaken safeguards for public lands, waterways, and culturally significant landscapes. Modeling suggests increased greenhouse gas emissions and premature deaths from air pollution. The Greater Chaco Region, Boundary Waters, and other previous places are examples of sites that are exposed and in the crosshairs for development. Who says please wait for a new Congress to do permitting reform correctly? The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), Sierra Club, Earthjustice, League of Conservation Voters, The Wilderness Society, Defenders of Wildlife, Friends of the Earth, Center for Biological Diversity, Southern Environmental Law Center, Western Environmental Law Center, Oceana, Union of Concerned Scientists, Endangered Species Coalition, Clean Water Action. Do we think these organizations are not concerned about climate change?

 11. Amendments have not settled the fundamental disagreements.

The Senate Manager’s Amendment did not address the above objections and there is no realistic chance that additional Senate or House amendments will do so or that they will be accepted, because the terrible consequences outlined above ARE THE POINT for some the bill’s sponsors.

 Your Leadership and the House’s Responsibility

The Senate’s procedural advance does not resolve your responsibility, or that of the House, to examine the legislation. Your concerns about House involvement and the attacks on Tribal sovereignty and Rep. Huffman’s objections to a sprawling deal without hearings underscore how much remains unsettled. The new Congress would have the opportunity to investigate the bill’s actual effects, consider alternatives, and negotiate with a different political balance. What Congress cannot responsibly assume is that a faster vote means faster clean energy, lower bills, or better outcomes for Americans.

The stakes extend beyond any one administration or development project. Once Congress changes the rules governing federal discretion, community participation, Tribal consultation, and judicial enforcement, those changes will shape decisions for generations. We implore you to use your leadership to ensure that these consequences receive full examination before the House acts.

Sincerely,

Greg Werkheiser, Attorney, Founding Partner, Cultural Heritage Partners, PLLC

On behalf of 106 Strong

Share this post